This is my proposal to end the Israeli Palestinian conflict. Egypt will be given the West Bank enlarged by land equivalent to the Gaza Strip. In return, Israel will be given the Gaza Strip and land at least 3 times larger than the West Bank in the Sinai Peninsula. Some of the land will be adjacent to water so Israel can build desalination plants. The Sinai is inhospitable, and Egypt doesn’t have the technology to develop it, but Israel does. With its new land, Egypt can give it to the Palestinians, make it a state within Egypt, or whatever it wants.
The west bank is palestinians, rgypt has no right to get it. Israel is illegally colonizing and occupying other people land, they have to return it all. Israel want to get it all with their grester Israel project.
Are you aware that Bedouin exist? That an area not being solid fields and cities on a map doesn’t mean people can just be resettled there without consequences? How Palestinians feel about Egypt, by and large?
How about we abolish the idea of ethnostates at all and a policy of reparation amd reform is put into place as an actually democratic state is created. And Smotrich, Ben-Gvir, and Netanyahu are schekht. They aren’t kosher regardless of ritual, but maybe it’ll purify them at least a little bit.
Ethnostates should not exist, but countries want to maintain a cultural identity. That’s the reason large influxes of migrants are causing resentment in Europe.
I’m sorry, but your plan is just letting Israeli perform another Nakba, and that’s horrible. If that’s the level of planning you’re coming up with, we might as well just have the whole world militarily force Israelis out of the area. Making Palestinians lose more of their land is the last thing we want.
This is my proposal to end the Israeli Palestinian conflict. Egypt will be given the West Bank enlarged by land equivalent to the Gaza Strip. In return, Israel will be given the Gaza Strip and land at least 3 times larger than the West Bank in the Sinai Peninsula. Some of the land will be adjacent to water so Israel can build desalination plants. The Sinai is inhospitable, and Egypt doesn’t have the technology to develop it, but Israel does. With its new land, Egypt can give it to the Palestinians, make it a state within Egypt, or whatever it wants.
Ah yes, more ethnic cleansing because “hey, they’re all Arab anyways”. Some of the most racist shit I’ve seen today.
What? Under my proposal Palestinians would have a homeland although under Egyptian control.
A homeland under someone else’s control isn’t a homeland.
Yes, it is. A place that is rented is a home. Palestine could be a state within Egypt.
Nah egypt return nothing. Israel return everything they occupied after 67
Egypt isn’t returning anything. It will be exchanging land in the Sinai for the West Bank and land equivalent to Gaza.
The west bank is palestinians, rgypt has no right to get it. Israel is illegally colonizing and occupying other people land, they have to return it all. Israel want to get it all with their grester Israel project.
Under my proposal Egypt is getting the West Bank in exchange for giving Israel a portion of the Sinai. How do you plan to get Israel to return it all?
Again israel want to steal more land. Colonizers was always forced to return land
How do you plan to force Israel to return land?
Resistance, bds and continue to push countries to stop defending Israel.
The US won’t stop supporting Israel. My proposal would give Palestinians a homeland although controlled Egypt.
Are you aware that Bedouin exist? That an area not being solid fields and cities on a map doesn’t mean people can just be resettled there without consequences? How Palestinians feel about Egypt, by and large?
There are Bedouins in the Sinai but not many. Israel can employ them. Do Palestinians prefer to be ruled by Egypt or Israel?
edit: Actually this isn’t worth dignifying with a response in the first place.
How about we abolish the idea of ethnostates at all and a policy of reparation amd reform is put into place as an actually democratic state is created. And Smotrich, Ben-Gvir, and Netanyahu are schekht. They aren’t kosher regardless of ritual, but maybe it’ll purify them at least a little bit.
Ethnostates should not exist, but countries want to maintain a cultural identity. That’s the reason large influxes of migrants are causing resentment in Europe.
I dont think Egypt wants the palestinians, unfortunately
I don’t think Palestinian want to be ethenically cleansed to egypt especially when israel want greater israel which would include egypt
If Israel takes over Palestinian land, they’re going somewhere. My proposal would give them a homeland under Egyptian control.
If we return Palestinian lands to Palestinians, Israelis have to go somewhere, as well.
They would return to Israel, but how do you plan to get Israelis to leave? Under my plan, Israel would get land in the Sinai.
I’m sorry, but your plan is just letting Israeli perform another Nakba, and that’s horrible. If that’s the level of planning you’re coming up with, we might as well just have the whole world militarily force Israelis out of the area. Making Palestinians lose more of their land is the last thing we want.
There are not many Bedouins in the Sinai. Israel can employ them.